My_name_1s_MUD wrote:
Ha. Nice try. Illini does less with more talent year in and year out. Our bowl losses were arguably some of the most exciting bowl games of their respective years. Double overtime losses to Jeremy Maclin, Chase Daniel, and Chase Coffman. As well as double overtime to Auburn, the year before they won the national championship. And let's not forget what shape the team was in when Fitzgerald "inherited" it. No, my friend. There is a reason why you hear about Fitzgerald for the Michigan, Penn State and ND jobs and you hear about Zook doing backroom deals to get top players. I know which coach I'd want to support (and that's without my purple colored glasses).
At some point, "does more with less" becomes Fitzgerald's fault. Recruit some damn players. Speaking of which, what does Fitzgerald do, exactly? He's not responsible for the defense or the offense. Recruiting hasn't improved under him. At best, Fitzgerald is a cheerleader, designed to help promote the I'm OK, You're OK mentality of the Northwestern athletic department.
Exhibit 1 of that mentality: Boasting about exciting bowl games against mid-tier teams that you lose. Exhibit 2: scheduling the following teams OOC over the past four years: Northeastern, Duke, Nevada (bad Nevada, not death ray Nevada), Eastern Michigan, Syracuse, Duke again, Southern Illinois, Ohio, Towson, Eastern Michigan again, Syracuse again, Vanderbilt, Rice, Illinois State, Central Michigan. Combined records of the D-I teams? 38-107. Northwestern's BCS conference opponents (Duke, Syracuse, and Vanderbilt): 14-44! (And Fitzgerald managed to lose one of those games, at home, to a 1-11 Duke team.) Without patsy scheduling, Northwestern doesn't make the fantastically exciting bowl games they invariably lose.
That's been the difference between Illinois and Northwestern between the past four years. In all other in-conference respects they've been essentially the same team. If equality with Northwestern is an indictment of Zook, fine, though in fairness to Zook Illinois has sucked long before he arrived and will likely such long after. Fitzgerald took over a Northwestern program that went 17-23 in the five years in the Big Ten before him (when the conference was better, honestly) and went 18-22 since.
If Penn State wants that, cool; they're in Illinois's division. I encourage it. But I think that contract is going to look an awful lot like an albatross around the neck of the athletic department in a couple of years.