TurdFerguson wrote:
Nas wrote:
http://www.draftexpress.com/nba-pre-draft-measurements/?year=2012&sort2=DESC&draft=0&pos=0&source=NBA%20Draft%20Combine&sort=14
Here is my problem with your argument. You are picking and choosing who and how she plays to say she belongs. You are quoting stats to say she is league average in height and weight and saying she is bigger than many players in the league and there fore she could play in the paint. What next, she shoots a better FT% than D Howard so she belongs? You site Reggie Miller as someone she may be able to muscle over. Reggie wasn't a muscle player and god help him if he banged in the paint. It wasn't his game. He was an elite shooting guard that could shake his shadow for an open look.
Yes, she may be able to over power reggie miller in the block. And looking at this list of players from draftexpress, I bet JaMychal Green could also over power Reggie in the paint. JaMychal was 3rd in bench press on that list, is 6'9' and 217 a 7'2 wingspan and a max vert of 32 inches. And was undrafted.
Can we agree based him being undrafted, that he doesn't belong in the NBA?
Do you think he could go Jiwuana Mann on Baylor's team and lead them to a National Title and put up similar stats to her. If you do think she belongs, then she must be able to do something that he can't.
I would love it if she could, but its just absurd.
I'm not really picking and choosing anything. The stats are a factual counter to the opinions held by many in this thread.
Looking at the list from draft express some of the top draft picks couldn't lift and as you pointed out one of the strongest men in the draft didn't get selected. That actually supports my point that strength isn't everything. Kevin Durant not being able to lift 185 is another fine example of strength not mattering. So once we get beyond the height and strength stuff we get down to skill.
Being undrafted doesn't mean he doesn't belong. The NBA talent evaluators miss on good to great players nearly every draft. Some fall to the 2nd round and others don't get draft.
Of course a strong man can play the role of Shaq and dominate women. That's not what Griner did in college though.
Saying it's absurd is wrong IMO. We've seen YouTube clips of lesser known/talented players holding their own against NBA players. It's not absurd to believe that a woman (possibly Griner) could play in the NBA.