sinicalypse wrote:
i personally think (as opposed to all that impersonal thinking i often do =) that soler's bat adds another dimension to the cubs lineup, or it shifts it into an even higher gear. there's just something about having another potentially big-boy .280/20-30/~100 RBI bat in there with that core of rizzo bryant and schwarber that's !!! and then with baez and russell creeping on the comeup, yeah, the cubs lineup just feels that much more complete with soler in there.
that said, i think his OF defense obviously leaves something to be desired, and right now whether it's injury or perhaps expecting too much too soon it's not like jorge has shown up and put up #s that FOR SURE screams out "THIS GUY IS .280/30/100 IF HE GETS 550+ ABS!!!!!" -- you saw some of that in 2014 when in ~24 games he had his ~100 ABs of .290/5/20 with a .902 OPS (aka "corey dickerson territory", or the guy i wanted the cubs to get in the 2013-14 offseason b4 he blew up for the rockies in 2014 like .310/24/76 with that .900+ OPS, cuz all corey dickerson does [when healthy] is put up a .900+ OPS) but then last year's (admittedly injury-riddled) sophomore season saw him drop to ~100 games / ~400 at bats of .262/10/47 with a .723 OPS, which isn't quite that .924 career minor league OPS you've known and love.
so yeah, this year is going to be a huge year for soler as we're likely going to find out just what he is/can-be at the big league level. is he going to be that ~.900/+ OPS guy that we saw in the minors and his 2014 cup of coffee? or is he going to have injury problems that help him regress to a .700something OPS, cuz last year's .723 OPS was far from inspiring, even tho in the playoffs he's a career .474 hitter with a 1.100 SLG% good for a 1.705 OPS... wowzers he had a good playoff run!
with that promise from the 2015 playoffs, yeah, if you can swing a deal for someone !!! under the auspices that you're getting value for a .900+ OPS guy, then i'd say go ahead and do it and risk the potential for him to out and be a total stud..... especially cuz doing that eschews the chance of him getting ~550 ABs of .258/16/72/4 with a .761 OPS.... or hell say he starts having more injury problems and can only muster another ~300-400 ABs again.... well then his trade value decreases significantly and it's like "why didnt you trade him this offseason when his playoff performances had ppl thinking he was that .900+ OPS guy?"
so yeah, go ahead and trade him if you want (ESPECIALLY if you go get heyward to replace/upgrade him defensively) but just make sure you get something good for him. you gotta do better than adam warren with soler.... go get heaney from the angels and impress me, OK? =D
Remember, they thought so highly of him when the playoffs started that he was sitting on the bench