From the same thread
IMU wrote:
One caveat...a World Series is the ultimate goal, and it should be. BUT
I wouldn't call this rebuild a failure if the Cubs, from 2015-2020...appear in the World Series and lose...and maybe have 1 or 2 other NLCS appearances....only miss the playoffs once or twice in that period with teams that were right in the thick of it at the end.
I really want a World Series...but not at the cost of having to write off a bunch of other years. It shouldn't ever have to be that way. I want to be competitive in September. I want to watch my team in October. I could pat Theo and Jed on the back when all is said and done even without a World Series... more of a "fantastic effort" pat on the back. It would still be the best extended period of success in Cubs baseball since before World War II.
IMU wrote:
I want both / more. Call me greedy, it's cool.
I'd prefer homegrown talent being the main reason for a win, but this is not required. I just wanted to provide some background to me and how I am as a fan.
But what is required of the Cubs, by me, as the trade-off to sacrificing seasons on purpose...is a better period of success than the White Sox had surrounding their 2005 season. Two playoff appearances in 14 seasons, even if one resulted in a World Series, is not enough.
If I had the time and patience to come up with a point season, I would. But for quick shits and gigs:
World Series win = 50 points
World Series Appearance = 25 Points
NLCS Appearance = 20 points
Playoff Appearance (not counting Wildcard game, fuck that)= 15 points
90+ Win Season but no playoffs = 10 points
81-89 Win Season but no playoffs = 5 Points
Rules are you can only receive one set of points per season...so you don't get all the points for winning the World Series in a season. You get 50.
The Cubs, from 2016-2020, need to score at least...let's say... 90 points using this system for me to be "happy" with this rebuild. 70 points to be "content."
And don't criticize it that much, I quickly whipped it together. I did not try every combination of end-season results to see if this is truly accurate to how I feel. But it should give you an idea.
On this scale, from 2004 - 2008, the White Sox achieved an 80.
World Series win is 50, Playoff Appearance is 15, 90+ win season is 10, and 83 win season is 5.
EDIT: I'm still at the fucking office at 8:15 PM. Shit like this is why. lol.
Thanks for finding this thread Frank. I had trouble finding it. This was the thread with my famous point system.
EDIT: Theo was so ahead of schedule, I didn't even think to put 2015-2020.